9th Circuit to Decide First Amendment Right to Run Tattoo Business
Hermosa Beach, California has a ban on tattoo businesses. Johnny Anderson owns the Yer Cheat’n Heart tattoo parlor in Gardena, California and wants to relocate to Hermosa Beach so much he’s taking his fight to the federal appeals court. Anderson argues that the ban on tattoo busineses violates constitutional free speech rights. A federal judge ruled in 2008 that Anderson’s tattooing was “not sufficiently imbued with elements of communication” to qualify as constitutionally protected speech.
At issue in the case is whether tattoos are classified as art. Although the First Amendment refers specifically to the freedoms of speech and press, it in fact encompasses a wide range of expression beyond publications and the spoken word. All art forms — including plays, music, dance, film, literature, poetry and the visual arts — enjoy considerable First Amendment protection. Hermosa Beach officials argue in court papers that Anderson isn’t engaged in expression but “merely providing a service.” The city also cites health risks, “aesthetic concerns,” small tax revenue, and a financial burden on the city to provide adequate inspection and regulation to justify its ban on tattoo businesses.
UC Berkeley law professor and 1st Amendment expert Jesse Choper doubts the total ban on tattoo parlors will pass constitutional review. He believes Hermosa Beach might have a chance of prevailing with the 9th Circuit judges if it imposed regulations limiting the practice to certain parts of the city or required the involvement of medical professionals.
http://articles.latimes.com/2010/may/23/local/la-me-tattoo-speech-20100524
http://www.topix.com/forum/city/redondo-beach-ca/TEH8RRRUU8VAB9EK2
Related posts:
- Supreme Court to Decide Public Display of Religious Monuments Case A small religious group called Summum has sued Pleasant Grove...
- D.C. Handgun Ban Amendment The Washington D.C. City Council passed a temporary amendment to...
- Farmworkers Claim City Violated Free Speech Rights A group of farm workers in Bridgeton, New Jersey filed...
- Court Upholds Church Polling Sites Last week, a federal judge ruled that placing polling booths...
- Florida Judge Rules City’s Baggy Pants Law Unconstitutional Palm Beach Circuit Court Judge Paul Moyle held Tuesday that...
Tags: First Amendment, Hermosa Beach, Tattoos
This entry was posted
on Tuesday, May 25th, 2010 at 7:05 am and is filed under Free Speech.
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
Both comments and pings are currently closed.
